HORIBA
  • Products
    • By Segment
      • Automotive
      • Medical
      • Process and Environmental
      • Semiconductor
      • Scientific
    • All Products (A-Z)
    • By Industry
      • Arts, Entertainment and Recreation
        • Art Conservation
        • Museums, Historical Sites and Similar Institutions
      • Education, R&D and Government Institutions
        • Universities
        • Research and Testing Laboratories
      • Energy and Environment
        • Battery
        • Coal and Consumable Fuels
        • Electric Utilities
        • Energy Fuel Oil
        • Environmental Countermeasures
        • Oil and Gas
        • Petroleum and Coal Products Manufacturing
      • Food and Beverage
        • Beverages
        • Food
        • Cosmetics
      • Health Care
        • Biotechnology
        • HORIBA In Vitro Diagnostic solutions for human health care
        • Life Sciences
        • Pharmaceuticals and Medicine Manufacturing
      • Industrials
        • Building Products
        • Commercial and Professional Services
        • Electrical Equipment
        • Machinery
      • Information Technology
        • Semiconductor Manufacturing Process
      • Materials
        • Chemicals
        • Chemical Manufacturing
        • Containers and Packaging
        • Nonferrous Metals
        • Nonmetallic Minerals
        • Paper, Forest Products and Manufacturing
        • Plastics and Rubber
        • Primary Metals
      • Mobility and Transportation
        • Automobiles and Components
        • Automotive Manufacturing
        • Other Transportation Equipment Manufacturing
      • Waste Management
        • Solid Waste Management and Remediation Services
        • Water Waste Management and Remediation Services
      • Water
        • Desalination
        • Drinking Water Utilities
        • High Purity Water
        • Other Industry Water
        • Water Reuse
    • By Technique
      • Atomic Spectroscopy
        • Energy Dispersive X-ray Fluorescence (ED-XRF)
        • Glow Discharge Optical Emission Spectrometry (GD-OES)
        • Inductively Coupled Plasma - Optical Emission Spectroscopy (ICP-OES)
        • Inorganic Elemental Analysis
        • Beta-ray Absorption Analyzer
      • Electrochemistry
        • Potentiometry based on Ion-Selective Electrode (ISE)
      • Life Science Techniques
        • Label-free Detection / Surface Plasmon Resonance Imaging (SPRi)
      • Mass Spectrometry
        • Plasma Profiling Time-Of-Flight Mass Spectrometry (PP-TOFMS)
        • Quadrupole Mass Spectrometry
      • Material Characterization
        • Colorimetry
        • Condensation Particle Counter (CPC)
        • Dynamic Light Scattering (DLS) Particle Size Distribution Analysis
        • Magneto-pneumatic Analysis
        • Mechanical Flowmetry
        • Pressure-based Mass Flowmetry
        • Spectroscopic Ellipsometry
        • Static Light Scattering (SLS) / Laser Diffraction Particle Size Distribution Analysis
        • Fluid Measurement and Control
      • Molecular Spectroscopy
        • Absorption and Transmission Spectroscopy (UV, Visible, NIR)
        • Cathodoluminescence (CL, CLUE)
        • Chemiluminescence
        • Fluorescence Spectroscopy
        • Fourier-Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FTIR)
        • Non-Dispersive Infrared Spectroscopy (NDIR)
        • Non-Dispersive Ultra Violet Spectroscopy (NDUV)
        • Photoluminescence (PL) & Electroluminescence (EL)
        • Quantum Cascade Laser (QCL) Spectroscopy
        • Raman Imaging and Spectroscopy
        • Vacuum Ultra Violet Spectroscopy
      • Radioactivity
        • Crystal Scintillation
      • Surface Science Techniques
        • Plasma Profiling Time-Of-Flight Mass Spectrometry (PP-TOFMS)
        • AFM-Raman (co-localized measurements & TERS)
  • Applications
    • Arts, Entertainment and Recreation
      • Art Conservation
      • Museums, Historical Sites and Similar Institutions
    • Education, R&D and Government Institutions
      • Universities
      • Research and Testing Laboratories
    • Energy and Environment
      • Coal and Consumable Fuels
      • Electric Utilities
      • Energy Fuel Oil
        • Wear metals and additive Elements Analysis.
      • Environmental Countermeasures
      • Petroleum and Coal Products Manufacturing
        • Petrochemicals
      • Photovoltaics
      • Oil and Gas
      • RoHS and ELV
    • Food and Beverage
      • Agriculture & Crop Science
      • Research & Development
      • Beverages
      • Food
      • Food & Beverage Manufacturing
    • Health Care
      • Biochemistry
      • Biotechnology
        • High Throughput Screening of Affimer Proteins using SPRi Label-Free Technology
        • Analytical Chemistry
      • Human Health Care
      • Life Sciences
        • Cell Biology
        • Blood Testing
        • Proteomics
        • Microbiology
        • Structural Biology
        • Genomics
        • Bioengineering
        • Nanoscience
        • Personal Care
      • Pharmaceuticals and Medicine Manufacturing
        • Cosmetics
        • Drug Discovery and Development
        • Drug Delivery
        • Counterfeit
        • Quality Assurance
        • Vacuum Monitoring in Dryer Equipment for Freeze Dry in Pharmaceuticals and Medicine Manufacturing
        • Bioprocessing
        • Analytical Chemistry
    • Industrials
      • Battery
      • Commercial and Professional Services
        • Gas mass flow control and measurement for reference value of PM2.5 measurement
      • Construction & Engineering
      • Electrical Equipment
      • Machinery
    • Information Technology
      • Semiconductors
        • 2D Materials
        • Graphene
        • Photovoltaics
        • Determination of Perovskite Optical Constants
        • Display Technologies
        • Data Storage
        • Nanomaterials
      • Semiconductor Manufacturing Process
      • Technology Hardware and Equipment
    • Materials
      • Ceramics
      • Chemicals
        • Fertilizers, phyo-sanitary
        • Polymers & Plastics
        • Analytical Chemistry
      • Chemical Manufacturing
      • Construction Materials
      • Containers and Packaging
        • Quality control in the aluminium packaging industry
      • Metal Powder
      • Nonferrous Metals
      • Nonmetallic Minerals
        • Glass
        • Coatings
      • Paper, Forest Products and Manufacturing
      • Plastics and Rubber
      • Primary Metals
      • Material Research
        • Corrosion
        • 2D Materials
        • Quantum Dots
        • Carbon based Materials - Graphene
        • Nanomaterials
      • Photovoltaics
      • Forensics
      • Metal and Mining
        • Gemstones
    • Mobility and Transportation
      • Automotive Manufacturing
      • Engine, Turbine and Power Transmission Equipment Manufacturing
      • Real Driving Emissions
      • RDE Plus
    • Waste Management
      • Solid Waste Management and Remediation Services
      • Water Waste Management and Remediation Services
        • Repeatability of Traces and Major Elements in Water
        • Very Rapid Analysis of Supply Water, Sludge From Purification Station and Animal Food
        • Waste Water and Soil Analysis
        • Waste Water Treatment and Disposal
    • Water
      • Drinking Water Utilities
      • Water Reuse
        • Water Testing
      • General Water Measurement
  • Technology
    • Measurement and Control Techniques
      • Electrochemistry
        • The Story of pH
        • The Basis of pH
        • Measurement of pH
        • The Story of Ion
        • The Basis of Ion
        • Measurement of Ion
        • The Story of ORP
        • The Basis of ORP
        • Measurement of ORP
        • The Story of Conductivity
        • The Basis of Conductivity
        • Measurement of Conductivity
        • The Story of Salt
        • The Story of Dissolved Oxygen
        • The Basis of DO Measurement
        • LAQUA Electrode Technology
      • Elemental Analysis
        • X-ray Fluorescence Spectroscopy (XRF)
        • Glow Discharge Optical Emission Spectroscopy
        • Inductively Coupled Plasma - Optical Emission Spectroscopy (ICP-OES)
        • Carbon/Sulfur & Oxygen/Nitrogen/Hydrogen Analysis
      • Health Care
        • Multi Distribution Sampling System (MDSS)
        • Reticulocytes Analysis
        • CBC + CRP
        • Slide Production
        • Automatic Rerun
        • Absorbance
        • Fluorescence
        • Flow cytometry
        • Impedance / Resistivity
        • Sedimentation
        • Spectrophotometry
        • Potentiometry
        • INR screening
        • Clotting
        • Turbidimetric
        • Chromogenic
      • Light Scattering
        • Dynamic Light Scattering (DLS) Particle Size Distribution Analysis
        • Molecular Weight
        • Raman Scattering
        • Static Light Scattering (SLS) / Laser Diffraction Particle Size Distribution Analysis
        • Zeta Potential
      • Fluid Control
        • Thermal Mass Flowmetry
      • Mass Spectrometry
        • Quadrupole Mass Spectrometry
      • Microscopy and Imaging
        • AFM-Raman
        • Atomic Force Microscopy [AFM]
        • Cathodoluminescence
        • Image Analysis of Particles
        • Micro-X-ray Fluorescence
      • Physisorption
        • Surface Area
      • Spectroscopy
        • Cathodoluminescence Spectroscopy
        • AFM-Raman
        • Detectors
        • 50 years of Diffraction Gratings
        • Diffraction Gratings Ruled and Holographic
        • Fluorescence Spectroscopy
        • Raman Spectroscopy
        • Spectrometers, Monochromators and Spectrographs
        • Spectroscopic Ellipsometry
        • Vacuum Ultra Violet Spectroscopy
        • X-ray Fluorescence
      • Surface Plasmon Resonance
        • Surface Plasmon Resonance Imaging (SPRi)
  • Service
    • Analysis Services
      • Analysis Centers and Services
      • EMC Analysis Service
    • Calibration and Certification
      • Calibration Centers
    • Customer Support
      • HORIBA Medical Documentation Database
      • Medical Customer Support
      • On-Site Support
      • Software Upgrades
      • STARS Helpdesk
    • Maintenance
      • Dynamometer and Other Overhaul Services
      • Periodic Maintenance
    • Spare Parts and Consumables
    • Testing and Consulting
      • Testing Centers
    • Training
      • Product Training
        • Scientific Product Training
        • Automotive Product Training
        • Medical Product Training
      • Technology Training
        • Raman Training
        • Glow Discharge Training
        • Fluorescence Training
        • Ellipsometry Training
        • SPRi Training
        • Inductively Coupled Plasma Training
        • Inductively Coupled Plasma Training (USA)
        • PSA Training
        • Carbon, Sulfur, Oxygen, Nitrogen and Hydrogen Analyzers Training (USA)
        • Online-OnSite Training
  • Company
    • About HORIBA
      • Message
      • Company Profile
        • Board of Directors
        • Corporate Officers
      • Culture
        • Corporate Philosophy
      • History
        • 1945–1960s
        • 1970s
        • 1980s
        • 1990s
        • 2000s
        • 2010s
      • Technical Journal "Readout"
        • Masao Horiba Awards Research Articles
        • Readout No. E54 - Microplastics and Nanoplastics: Analysis and Method Development
        • Readout No. E53 - 2019 Masao Horiba Awards - Advanced Analytical and Measurement Technologies for Efficient Control System to Maximize the Performance of Electric Power and Batteries Usage
        • Readout No. E52 - Green Innovation for Marine Shipping Industry
        • Readout No. E51 - 2018 Masao Horiba Awards Advanced analytical and measurement technologies in semiconductor manufacturing processes
        • Readout No. E50 - Low-Carbon Society and Environmental Improvement
        • Readout No. E49 - Photonic Instrumentation in Life Science
        • Readout No. E48 - Water Measurement Experts
        • Readout No. E47 - Application for Semiconductor Manufacturing Process
        • Readout No. E46 - New Development for Automotive Test Systems
        • Readout No. E45 - Application Technology in Analysis
        • Readout No. E44 - Contribution of Diagnostics to Total Medical Care/Healthcare
        • Readout No. E43 - Watching the Environmental and Society with Measurements
        • Readout No. E42 - More Efficient Testing on Automotive Development, Improving the Accuracy of Fuel Consumption Measurement
        • Readout No. E41 - Application
        • Readout No. E40 - Application
        • Readout No. E18 - EUROPE
        • Readout No. E17 - AMERICA
        • Readout No. E16 - Chinese (Asia)
        • Readout No. E15 - Technologies for HORIBA STEC
        • Readout No. E14 - Masao HORIBA Awards"Measurement of Bioparticles" and "Measurement of Internal Combustion"
        • Readout No. E13 - Technologies for Automotive Testing
        • Readout No. E12 - Masao Horiba Awards "X-ray Analysis Technology"
        • Readout No. E11 - The Second Masao Horiba Awards
        • Readout No. E10 - Environmental Analysis Technologies for the Management of Global Environment and the Development of Industry
        • Readout No. E09 - The First Dr.Masao Horiba's Award and the 50th Anniversary Products
        • Readout No. E08 - Products and Technologies of HORIBA ABX
        • Readout No. E07 - Products and Technologies of Jobin Yvon HORIBA Group
        • Readout No. E06 - 50th Anniversary of HORIBA, Ltd. Products and Technology of HORIBA Group
        • Readout No. E05 - Semiconductor Instruments
        • Readout No. E04 - Hematology Instruments
        • Readout No. E03 - Paticulate Matter
        • Readout No. E02 - The Technolgy Alliance for X-ray Analysis
        • Readout No. E01 - the Analysis of the Global Environment
      • Virtual Patent Marking
    • Events
    • Career
    • Investor Relations
      • Home
      • Investor Relations News
      • Management Policies
        • Message from the CEO
        • Mid-Long Term Management Plan
        • Corporate Governance
        • Corporate Culture "Joy and Fun"
        • Corporate Philosophy
      • IR Library
        • Financial Statements
        • Presentation Materials
        • HORIBA Report
        • Financial Information
      • Stock Information
        • Basic Stock Information
      • Investor Relations Contact
      • Other IR Information
        • Investor Relations Calendar
        • Disclaimer
    • News
    • Social Responsibility
      • Home
      • Message
      • HORIBA's CSR
        • CSR Policy, CSR Promotion System
        • UN Global Compact
        • HORIBA and the SDGs
      • Environment
        • Policy
        • Environmental Activities
        • Eco-Friendly Products
        • Actions for RoHS Directive, REACH Regulation and GHS Regulations
      • Social
        • Home
        • Integrated Management System
        • Quality
        • Occupational safety and health
        • Promotion of Diversity
        • Material Procurement
        • Social Activities
      • Governance
        • Corporate Governance
        • Code of Ethics
        • Internal Controls
        • Compliance Promotion Systems
        • Risk Management
      • HORIBA Special Contents
      • Library
      • HORIBA Group Social Media
        • Social Media Registered Accounts
        • HORIBA Group Social Media Policy
        • HORIBA Group Terms of Use for Social Media
      • Integrated Report
    • Group Companies
      • Americas
        • Brazil
        • Canada
        • United States
      • Asia
        • China
        • India
        • Indonesia
        • Japan
        • Korea
        • Philippines
        • Singapore
        • Taiwan
        • Thailand
        • Vietnam
      • Europe
        • Austria
        • Belgium
        • Czech Republic
        • France
        • Germany
        • Italy
        • Netherlands
        • Poland
        • Portugal
        • Romania
        • Russia
        • Spain
        • Sweden
        • Turkey
        • United Kingdom
  • Contact
    • Contact Form
    • Worldwide Locations
Glow Discharge Optical Emission Spectroscopy (GD-OES) open open
  • Basic Concepts
  • Sample Measurement with GDOES
  • Sample Test and Analysis
  • Comparison with Other Techniques: Surface Analysis
  • Comparison with Other Techniques: Bulk Analysis
  • Instrument Introduction
  • Benefits and Features of Pulsed RF GDOES
  • Join the GD Community
  • Bibliography
  • HORIBA
    • Products
    • Applications
    • Technology
    • Service
    • Company
    • Contact
    Technology
    • Measurement and Control Techniques
    Measurement and Control Techniques
    • Basic Concepts
    • Sample Measurement with GDOES
    • Sample Test and Analysis
    • Comparison with Other Techniques: Surface Analysis
    • Comparison with Other Techniques: Bulk Analysis
    • Instrument Introduction
    • Benefits and Features of Pulsed RF GDOES
    • Join the GD Community
    • Bibliography
    Comparison with Other Techniques: Bulk Analysis

Comparison with Other Techniques: Bulk Analysis

What are the differences between Pulsed RF GDOES and Spark?

Spark emission spectrometry, know for decades, is widely used for the chemical analysis of metals and alloys. In terms of overall performance for bulk analysis, GD and Spark are very comparable and therefore Spark is more widely used due to lower price and simplest operation mode.

However, GD is the necessary choice when one wants to perform depth profile analysis (which Spark cannot do) together with bulk. GD has also some benefits in some rare cases, due to its specific characteristic low Matrix Effect and linearity allowing easier extrapolations. GD is therefore used for precious metals or nodular cast iron (with Mg).

Matrix Effects and linearity of the calibrations

Microscopic view of an Al sample after analysis by Spark (left) and by GD (right).

Fig 59: Microscopic view of an Al sample after analysis by Spark (left) showing localized surface melting. The same Al sample analyzed by GD (right) reveals that the structure of the sample is maintained by the “soft” sputtering process.

In Spark, the atomization and excitation steps occur in the same step. The sample surface is locally melted and the sample material vaporized. The electric arcs of a Spark analysis can also be affected by microstructures and inhomogeneities in the material. Finally the emission lines in Spark are subject to strong self-absorption leading to second order calibration curves, the need to select several lines for the same element to cover the required concentration range, and great uncertainties when extrapolating results. Spark is finally very sensitive to surface oxidation (requiring sample polishing just before analysis).

GD separates the atomization and excitation processes. In GD, sample atoms are released through sputtering and further excited in the gas phase away from the sample surface. Therefore strict matrix-matching is not necessary in GD which is an advantage for complex alloys for which no Certified Reference Materials (CRM) are available.

In addition, GD is a low thermal process and offers linear calibration curves over orders of magnitude (generally from DL to 100%), therefore one line per element is the rule of thumb in GD. Finally GD averages signals over the entire sputtered area and is therefore less sensitive to local inhomogeneities.

Analysis of thin foils

GD is of interest when thin foils (less than 2 mm) have to be measured.

Fig 60: Thin foil analysis.

GD is of interest when thin foils (less than 2 mm) have to be measured. The photo below is an example. The thermal effects in Spark are too strong to measure these types of samples accurately, which cannot be easily polished prior to measurement.

There is not much difference in the overall speed of a complete analysis between Spark and GD: an individual Spark measurement is faster than a GD one (15 s vs 1 mn typically) but, in order to obtain representative information, several spots must be done at different locations requiring a manipulation of the sample between two analyses (and repolishing if the sample is small). In GD, the pre-integration time notably is longer than in Spark but successive measurements can then be done at the same location as the process continuously penetrates the sample and the previously  puttered material is continuously taken away.

What are the differences between Pulsed RF GDOES and XRF?

Multi-layered coin depth profile (not possible by XRF).

Fig 61: Multi-layered coin depth profile (not possible by XRF).

The two techniques are very different and rarely have to be compared. X-Ray techniques have limitations for light elements, which is not the case for GD.

Growing fields of interest in GD relate to Li batteries or H storage materials; H and Li cannot be measured with X-rays. For common elements, pulsed RF GDOES offers sensitivity superior to EDX but comparable to WDX.

X-ray instruments are sometimes also proposed for depth profile analysis. Depending on the incident energy the X-rays can penetrate more or less deeply in a material, and if the layer sequence is known, information on thickness can be derived. This might work for plated materials if the same element is not present in two layers (the sequence Au/Ni/Cu/glass can be measured where Au/Ni/Cu/Ni/glass will lead to errors). With X-rays, no sputtering is needed but low concentrations in the layers and potential contaminants at interfaces cannot be seen.

What are the differences between Pulsed RF GDOES and bulk HR GDMS?

Prior to the European project coordinated by HORIBA Scientific (www.emdpa.eu) that lead to the development of a brand new instrumentation type called Plasma Profiling TOFMS, the acronym “GDMS” was only used for a few instruments worldwide dedicated to ultra trace analysis of metals.

These instruments feature a magnetic sector sequential by design (they are therefore not adapted to depth profile analysis of thin layers) and DC sources limit them to conductive materials only. They can achieve outstanding Detection Limits (down to the sub ppb range) and have found niche applications for high purity material assessment.

  • Products
    • By Products (A-Z)
    • Automotive
    • Medical
    • Process and Environment
    • Scientific
    • Semiconductor
  • Applications
    • Drinking Water Utilities
    • Automotive Manufacturing
    • Semiconductor Manufacturing Process
    • Research and Testing Laboratories
  • Technology
    • Glow Discharge Spectroscopy
    • Pressure-based Flowmetry
    • Quadrupole Mass Spectrometry
    • Raman Spectroscopy
  • Service
    • On-Site Support
    • Spare Parts and Consumables
  • Company
    • News
    • Events
    • Career
    • History
    • Corporate Culture
  • Contact
    • Contact Form
    • Worldwide Locations

Terms and Conditions Privacy Notice Cookies Imprint